CHINESE ORIGINAL
道可道,非常道,名可名,非常名;无名,天地之始,有名,万物之母。
故常无欲,以观其妙,常有欲,以观其徼;此两者,同出而异名,同谓之玄。
玄之又玄,众妙之门。
ENGLISH · JAMES LEGGE, 1891
The Tao that can be trodden is not the enduring and unchanging Tao. The name that can be named is not the enduring and unchanging name.
(Conceived of as) having no name, it is the Originator of heaven and earth; (conceived of as) having a name, it is the Mother of all things.
Always without desire we must be found, If its deep mystery we would sound; But if desire always within us be, Its outer fringe is all that we shall see.
Under these two aspects, it is really the same; but as development takes place, it receives the different names. Together we call them the Mystery. Where the Mystery is the deepest is the gate of all that is subtle and wonderful.
A CONTEMPORARY READING
Modern English reading
The Way that can be spoken is not the constant Way; the name that can be named is not the constant name. The nameless is the beginning of heaven and earth; the named is the mother of all things. Thus, always without desire, observe its subtle wonder; always with desire, observe its boundaries. These two emerge together but have different names. Together they are called mysterious. Mystery upon mystery: the gateway of all wonders.
Modern English readings and commentary translations are AI-assisted study aids, not a published critical translation. Compare the Chinese source when wording matters.
Modern Chinese reading
可以用语言表述的道,不是永恒不变的道;可以用名称界定的名,不是永恒不变的名。无名是天地的开端,有名是万物的根源。所以,常从无中观察奥妙,常从有中观察端倪。无和有同源而名称不同,都可以说是深奥的。这种深奥又深奥,是一切奥妙的门户。
READ ACROSS TRADITIONS
Historical commentaries
Wang Fuzhi 王夫之
Elaboration of the Laozi
Manuscripts and variants
Differences are computed from transcribed Chinese characters, with punctuation excluded. ∅ marks an insertion or omission; highlights do not establish which reading is earlier.
Mawangdui silk manuscript 73% similarity · 19 changed spans
Received text · Wang Bi tradition
道可道∅非常道∅名可名∅非常名∅无名天地之始∅有名万物之母∅故常无欲∅以观其妙常有欲∅以观其徼此两者同出而异名同谓之玄玄之又玄众妙之门
Mawangdui silk manuscript
道可道也非恒道也名可名也非恒名也无名万物之始也有名万物之母也故恒无欲也以观亓眇恒有欲也以观亓所徼∅两者同出∅异名同谓∅玄∅之又玄众眇之门
Jinglong stone inscription 96% similarity · 5 changed spans
Received text · Wang Bi tradition
道可道非常道名可名非常名无名天地之始有名万物之母故常无欲以观其妙常有欲以观其徼此两者同出而异名同谓之玄玄之又玄众妙之门
Jinglong stone inscription
道可道非常道名可名非常名无名天地∅始有名万物∅母∅常无欲∅观其妙常有欲∅观其徼此两者同出而异名同谓之玄玄之又玄众妙之门
Internet transcription; not checked against inscription photographs.
This chapter is not in the attested Guodian A/B/C chapter list. Compare the whole book ↗
Expressions from this chapter
CHAPTER 1 · EXACT WORDING
道可道
The Way can be spoken of, but a spoken way is not the enduring Way.
道可道,非常道Read the source chapter ↗CHAPTER 1 · LATER ADAPTATION
非常之道
An extraordinary way. This later expression should be distinguished from chapter 1's “not the constant Way.”
道可道,非常道,名可名Read the source chapter ↗CHAPTER 1 · EXACT WORDING
天地之始
The beginning of heaven and earth.
无名,天地之始,有名Read the source chapter ↗CHAPTER 1 · EXACT WORDING
万物之母
The mother of the myriad things: the source from which they arise.
有名,万物之母Read the source chapter ↗CHAPTER 1 · EXACT WORDING
玄之又玄
Mystery upon mystery: something profoundly subtle.
玄之又玄,众妙之门Read the source chapter ↗READ IN CONTEXT
The Way
The source that cannot be fully named. Explore the language of emptiness, return, and the patterns through which things arise.
The Way
ENGLISH STUDY TRANSLATION
'The Way that can be spoken is not the constant Way.' The constant Way has no prescribed way. 'The name that can be named is not the constant name.' The constant name is nameless. 'Nameless: the beginning of heaven and earth.' All names emerge from it; it cannot itself have a name. 'Named: the mother of all things.' Names are established through things, and names in turn generate things. 'Thus constantly in nonbeing, wishing to observe its wonder; constantly in being, wishing to observe its boundary.' This means its limits. 'These two emerge together but have different names.' Their ways of being observed differ, but their constancy is the same. Thus having desire and having no desire do not require dividing the mind to respond. Abide in the center and hold to constancy, and contemplation of wonder and boundary follows of itself. 'Together they are called mysterious. Mystery upon mystery: the gateway of all wonders.'
What is 'possible' is not 'constant'; what is 'constant' has no particular 'possible.' Yet if one clings to 'constancy,' that constancy becomes one more fixed possibility. Therefore do not discard constancy, but fix on no particular possibility. Not discarding constancy lets human responsiveness flow freely; fixing on no possibility unifies heavenly harmony. There is already a 'beginning' and a 'mother,' and I provisionally join in 'observing' them. Such observation rides upon what cannot be otherwise. Observing their 'difference,' being and nonbeing shift countless times. Observing their 'sameness,' being arises later, while nonbeing is not itself the Great Beginning either. Going forth to respond reveals difference; remaining to await reveals sameness.
Thus one nourishes all things without claiming the credit for benevolence, enters the workings of contrivance without confronting their sharp edges, knows the world's feelings without forcing others to serve oneself, and relinquishes one's own excess without clinging to the old and becoming blind to the new. None can name one's achievement, so it is styled 'the many wonders.' To dwell in contentment with the meaning attained, opening the gate and passing through the birth and death of the hundred activities: how deeply at ease this is!
Chinese commentary
道可道,非常道。常道无道。名可名,非常名。常名无名。无名,天地之始;众名所出,不可以有名。有名,万物之母。名因物立,名还生物。故常无,欲以观其妙;常有,欲以观其徼。边际也。此两者,同出而异名,异观同常,则有欲无欲,非分心以应,居中执常,自致妙徼之观。同谓之玄。玄之又玄,众妙之门。
“可”者不“常”,“常”者无“可”。然据“常”,则“常”一“可”也,是故不废“常”,而无所“可”。不废“常”,则人机通;无所“可”,则天和一。夫既有「始」矣,既有「母」矣,而我聊与「观」之;「观」之者,乘于其不得已也。观于其”异”,则有无数迁;观于其“同”,则有者后起,而无者亦非大始也。然则往以应者见异矣,居以俟者见同矣。故食万物而不尸其仁,入机伪而不逢其锐;知天下之情,不强人以奉己;弃一己之余,不执故以迷新。是以莫能名其功,而字之曰「众妙」。盖其得意以居,开户而历百为之生死者,亦甚适矣夫!